What does ChatGPT say when a customer asks about you?
The AI answer check is a regular test, reported on your monthly page. We ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI features the questions your customers really ask, write down what they say about you, and fix wrong facts where they come from: your website, your listings and the hidden labels on your pages.
In one sentence: we put your customers' real questions to the AI tools they use, record exactly what each one says about your business, trace wrong facts back to where they came from, fix them there, and show you the before and after on your monthly page.
Do my customers really ask AI tools about local businesses?
Yes, and more each year. 45% of US consumers used an AI tool for local business recommendations in the past year, up from 6% the year before (BrightLocal, 2026). ChatGPT was the most used, at 31%, followed by Google's AI Mode at 23%. Among people aged 30 to 44, it was 64%.
People also click through less. When a Google search showed an AI summary, people clicked a regular result on 8% of visits, against 15% when there was no summary (Pew Research Center, 2025). More customers now judge you from the answer alone. If it has your old hours, they may never know.
The good news: people still check. 97% of AI users sometimes double-check an AI recommendation against real reviews (BrightLocal, 2026). That's why this check works hand in hand with your reviews and listings.
What can go wrong in an AI answer?
AI tools sound confident even when they're wrong. When one company asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity over 72,000 questions about UK high street shops, 64% of the businesses had at least one false fact returned about them. Wrong locations were the most common mistake, and about 1 in 15 website answers pointed to a dead link, a lookalike or a different business (Searchable, 2026). The same things happen to small businesses:
- Old facts that won't die. You moved two years ago. An old directory still lists the old address, and an AI tool repeats it to someone looking for directions.
- "They don't do that." Someone asks whether you fit heat pumps or see children. Your website never says so clearly, so the answer says no, or names someone else.
- Mixed up with a namesake. A business with a similar name in the next town gets your reviews, or you get theirs.
- Simply missing. The tool names three other businesses and not you, often because the facts about you online are thin or don't agree with each other.
Which questions do you ask?
We build a fixed set of 5 to 10 questions with you, from your real enquiries and the way your customers talk. A plumber's set might include "emergency plumber near me open on Sunday" and "Is [your business name] any good?". A clinic's set might ask who takes new patients on Saturdays, or what a first visit costs.
We ask the same set each time, in the same way, so changes mean something. AI answers vary by person, place and day, so one answer proves little. A trend across six months tells you a lot, and that's what your monthly page shows.
Where do AI tools get their facts about me?
Mostly from the same places a careful customer would look:
- Your own website. Your pages, and how clearly they state your services, hours, prices and the areas you cover.
- Your listings. Google Business Profile, Apple Maps, Bing, Yelp and the directories for your trade.
- Your reviews, and what customers say in them.
- Mentions on other sites. Local news, associations, suppliers, wedding blogs, tourism boards. In a study of 75,000 brands, mentions of a brand on other websites tracked visibility in Google's AI Overviews about three times as closely as links did (Ahrefs, 2025).
When these sources agree, AI tools tend to get you right. When they disagree, the tool has to guess.
What do you fix when an answer is wrong?
- Find the source. We work out where the wrong fact comes from: an old listing, an out-of-date page, a directory nobody remembers signing up to.
- Fix your website. Clear, simple statements of what you do, where, when and roughly what it costs, on the page where people expect them.
- Fix your listings. Google, Apple, Bing, Yelp and trade directories, so they all say the same thing. See listings care.
- Fix the hidden labels. Schema markup is a small set of labels in your page code that tells search engines and AI tools your name, address, hours and services in a format they read easily. We keep it matching what your page actually says.
- Report it. Where a tool lets you flag a wrong answer, we do, and we ask outside sites to correct their facts.
- Check again. Same questions, next time round. Your monthly page shows what changed.
Do I need special AI files or tricks?
No. Some agencies now sell "GEO" or "AEO" packages (generative engine or answer engine optimisation, meaning work aimed at AI answers). Google's own guidance is clear: "There are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, nor other special optimizations necessary." It adds that you don't need "new machine readable files, AI text files, or markup" (Google Search Central, 2025).
What does help is the ordinary work, done well: accurate facts, clear pages that answer real questions, current listings, honest reviews and being mentioned on other sites. Search engine optimisation (SEO), meaning the work of helping search engines understand and trust your site, still matters for exactly this reason.
AI tools decide their own answers
No outside company controls them, and they change often. Be careful with anyone who says they can get you "recommended by ChatGPT". What we can do is check what the tools say, keep a record, fix the facts behind the answers, and show you what changed.
The first answer is now often the only one people read.
of US consumers used an AI tool for local business recommendations in the past year, up from 6%
of Google visits with an AI summary led to a click on a regular result, against 15% without one
of UK high street retailers tested had at least one false fact in AI answers about them
The check, step by step.
The check is part of Full Care. It starts once the basics are fixed, usually in month three.
| What we do | When | What you see |
|---|---|---|
| Ask your question set in ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode | Regularly, same questions each time | "Named in 11 of 24 answers" |
| Record what each answer says about you, word for word | Each time we check | Any wrong fact, quoted |
| Trace each wrong fact to where it came from | When we find one | The source, in simple words |
| Fix your website, listings and schema | Soon after we find a problem | Before and after |
| Check AI and search bots can read your site | Regularly | "Readable by search and AI tools" |
| Add new questions from real enquiries | As they come in | Your next question set |
| Re-check after big changes: a move, new hours, a new service | Soon after the change | Confirmed, or what's still wrong |
Monthly page · October
Hi Tom, AI tools named you more often this month.
- We asked 4 AI tools 6 questions your customers ask. You were named in 11 of 24 answers, up from 7 in September
- Gemini still gives your old Mill Road address. It comes from an old trade directory. We asked them to correct it on Tuesday
- Perplexity said you don't install EV chargers. Your services page now says you do, with a short answer to that exact question
- Re-check the Mill Road answer in November
The Penguina team
Names and numbers changed for illustration.
Exactly what they said, and what we did about it.
Your monthly page shows how often you were named, what the tools got wrong, and what we changed. Your Monday note flags anything urgent, like a wrong phone number, once we find it.
- "Named in X of Y answers", with the same questions each time
- Wrong facts, quoted, with where they came from
- The fix, with a before and after
The AI answer check comes with Full Care.
Grow keeps your listings right, which already helps AI tools. Full Care adds the AI answer check, so you know what they actually say.
Keep
$100 / month
Your site safe, working and readable by search and AI tools.
- Protect, in full
- Your enquiries, by name
- AI answer check not included
Grow Recommended
$250 / month
Everything in Keep, plus the listings and reviews AI tools read.
- Google and listings care
- Reviews answered
- AI answer check not included
Full Care
$500 / month
Everything in Grow, plus the AI answer check and fixes.
- AI answer check, on your monthly page
- New pages for what people ask
- Review requests to your customers
Real work, reported word for word
We report what AI tools actually say about you, good or bad. Then we fix the facts at the source: your website, your Google profile and your listings. Google says no special "AI files" are needed, so we don't sell them.
Check it yourself, hire someone, or let us look after it?
You can check AI answers yourself in ten minutes. The hard part is keeping it up, and fixing what you find.
| Do it yourself | Freelancer or agency | Penguina | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Same questions asked each time | When you remember | Varies | Yes |
| Four AI tools, answers recorded word for word | One or two tools | Sometimes | Yes |
| Wrong facts traced to their source | Hard to do | Sometimes | Yes |
| Website, listings and schema fixed together | Partly | Often only one | All three |
| Trend over months, in simple words | No | A dashboard to log in to | On your monthly page |
| Honest about what nobody controls | Yes | Varies, some claim they can get you mentioned | Yes |
| Cost | Your time | Varies | Part of Full Care, $500 a month |
What customers ask AI, by business.
The questions change by trade. So do the facts that go wrong most often.
Helicopter tours
Visitors ask "best helicopter tour in" a region, and what it costs. AI tools often quote old prices from booking sites or travel blogs, so we keep your own prices and weather policy clear.
Plumbers
"Emergency plumber open now" is a question with no second chances. We check that AI answers have your real hours, the areas you cover and a working phone number.
Bed and breakfasts
Guests ask whether you take dogs, have parking or serve breakfast early. Answers often come from old travel listings, so we make your own site the clearest source.
Questions about the AI answer check.
Something else? Ask in the chat, email hello@penguina.website or WhatsApp us.
Can you get me recommended by ChatGPT?
Only the AI companies decide that. We make sure the facts about you are right and the same everywhere, which gives AI tools the best chance of getting you right. Then we show you what they say.
Why do the answers change from day to day?
AI tools build each answer fresh, and the result depends on the exact words, the person's location and what the tool found that day. That's why we ask the same questions the same way each time, and judge by the trend, not one answer.
Which AI tools do you check?
ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode. They're the ones customers use most today. If your customers start using another one, we add it.
Do I need an "AI file" on my website?
No. Google says you don't need special files or markup to appear in its AI features. We do make sure your site lets search and AI bots read it, and that your page labels match what your pages say.
Can AI tools read my website at all?
Sometimes they can't, because of a setting nobody remembers changing. We check that the bots used by Google, Bing, ChatGPT search and Perplexity are allowed in. Whether AI companies may use your pages to train their models is a separate choice, and we help you make it on purpose. See should you block AI training.
What if an AI tool says something false and damaging?
We find where it comes from and fix or report the source, use the tool's own feedback options, and tell you quickly. If it's a legal matter, we'll say so and suggest you speak to a lawyer. We don't give legal advice.
Is this different from SEO?
It overlaps. SEO helps search engines understand your site. The AI answer check looks at what AI tools actually say about you, and fixes the facts behind it. We don't sell rankings or SEO packages.
Can I check this myself?
Yes, and we'd encourage you to try. Ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity the questions your customers ask, and note anything wrong. The hard part is asking the same way every month, and fixing what you find.
Sources for the figures on this page
- BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2026, AI report (1,002 US consumers)
- Pew Research Center, July 2025 (900 US adults, browsing in March 2025)
- Searchable research, reported July 2026
- Ahrefs, An Analysis of AI Overview Brand Visibility Factors, May 2025 (correlation 0.664 for mentions vs 0.218 for links)
- Google Search Central, AI features and your website, last updated December 2025
Not sure where to start? Send us your website.
We look at it the way a customer would, find up to 3 real problems, and fix one of them free. No call needed.